|
|
 |
Tour Climbs, Chris Sidwells (2008)
Collins 9780007315215 Quarto 256pp £18.99
A useful catalogue of the Tours Cols that falters before the summit
 
|
Sir Hugh Munro almost certainly had no idea what he was unleashing on
the world when he started to compile his list of Scottish peaks over 3,000
feet. Nonetheless, by doing so, he kick-started a train-spotterish cult
of ticking off lists of peaks.
Those road passes that have featured in the Tour are an obvious sub-set
of mountain passages. And leafing through this lavishly-illustrated volume,
it is almost impossible not to start fashioning a plan to set about them
yourself.
Here are the Tourmalet, the Col d'Aspin, Alpe d'Huez and Ventoux - names
that have been burnished over the decades by Phil Liggett's annual intonations.
Each of the big climbs is accorded a spread, which includes a description
of the climb itself, historical notes on notable stages that have taken
that route, some tips for anyone planning to ride it themselves, a good
selection of photographs and a serpentine representation of the twists
and turns taken by the road.
The lesser climbs are represented by shorter entries, although all include
the length of the climb, maximum altitude and the gain on the road, as
well as details of the gradients.
Appealing as the book is, however, it does have significant shortcomings.
The most notable is the complete absences of maps. The book's chapters
divide the climbs into seven discreet areas - eastern Pyrenees, western
Pyrenees, and so on. You might expect a diagrammatic representation of
France showing just where there areas are - particularly, as Sidwells
acknowledges, his division of the Alps is a arbitrary one. Even more useful
would have been a map at the start of each chapter, giving some indication
of the mountains position in relation to each other.And each entry could
have done with something rather more useful than the squiggle that it
uses to represent the course of the road.
Were this book the product of a small publisher, such omissions might
be excusable. The owners of cartographic copyright are well known for
extracting substantial fees for the reproduction of their works. Collins,
however, and a massive company, with their own cartographic division and
are a subsidiary of News Corporation - the second biggest media company
on earth.
Occasionally the details throw up concerns, too. The roads over Ventoux
spend much of the year closed by snow, often well past Easter. There is
no mention of this in Sidwell's entry on the Giant of Provence. His readers
would not thank him to discover the snow gates closed as they sweated
their way towards the summit.
The book still has a lot going for it - but it could have been a great
deal better.
PS Jan 10
|
Bookmark this on Delicious
Follow the site!
Join our list we will let you known when new reviews
are added to the site. We will never share your email address with
third parties.
tim@timdawsn.demon.co.uk
You can also follow us on Facebook
|
Visit our sister site
for dispassionate, expert advice on general cycling
issues
|
How this site is organised
As reviews are added, they are featured on the
front page. All titles are listed in the master index and cross-referenced
in the other indicies.
The subject line contains the title, author and
date of each book's publication. As a general rule, we list the
date of the actual edition that we read, unless there is an obvious
reason to use the original date (say where we read a reprint).
The first line of the main text contains the name
of the publisher, the ISBN
number, where it exists, an indication of the book's
size and the number of printed pages that it contains. Finally,
where it is clear, I list the published price of the work in the
currency that is most prominently displayed.
We summarise the book in a single sentence or two
in the next line. The rest of the review is then intended as a self-contained
piece.
|
|
